Featured: Impact

Robert is unimpressed by at least one of the CGIAR’s 40 talents, “biological control of two devastating insect pests”.

This was about fixing what other researchers had broken when they shipped infected South American cassava to Africa. I understand it was fixed by finding a natural enemy in South America and bringing that to Africa as well.

It was great that the CGIAR did this, and employed an entomologist to do it, but there would have alternative suppliers aplenty. Any decent entomologist could have done that.

So wouldn’t this have happened anyway, perhaps a little bit later? If so the counter-factual is “basically the same result” (no impact). Entirely different thing from investing in a breeding program. Or a genebank.

And he has a nice little coda on using such efforts as a tool for extortion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *